For Catholics considering IVF or surrogacy, understanding how faith intersects with these reproductive technologies is can help you understand what your next steps are. The Catholic Church has a long-standing view on the sanctity of life and the natural process of conception, which shapes its stance on medical interventions like IVF.
Interested in learning how the surrogacy process works? Check out this article or contact us online now to connect with a specialist.
Whether you're pursuing surrogacy or are thinking about beginning IVF treatments, this article will guide you through the Catholic Church's stance on IVF and ethical debates while respecting your personal journey in building a family.
The Catholic Church and IVF: Statements from the Vatican
The Vatican’s official stance on IVF has been clear in several documents. Donum Vitae (1987) condemned the practice of IVF because it separates the procreative act from the conjugal union. In 2008, Dignitas Personae (The Dignity of a Person) expanded on these teachings, condemning practices like the destruction of embryos and the selection of embryos based on genetic traits.
The document emphasized the need to respect every human life, from conception to natural death, and raised ethical concerns over the commodification of human life through IVF.
Is IVF a Sin in The Catholic Church?
The Catholic’s teachings on IVF are rooted in the belief that life is sacred from the moment of conception. According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, every human being has inherent dignity because they are made in the image and likeness of God.
This belief extends to the natural process of procreation, where conception should occur through an act of love between a husband and wife. Any intervention that separates conception from this union is viewed as contrary to divine law.
The Catholic opinion on IVF also states that medical technologies should respect human dignity and life. While it supports medical interventions to help with natural conception, methods like IVF, which involve the creation of life outside the womb, present ethical concerns within Catholic doctrine.
What Does the Pope Say About IVF?
More recently, the Church has upheld this stance through papal statements and official teachings. Pope Benedict XVI and Pope Francis have both echoed concerns about IVF’s potential to devalue human life, particularly in cases where embryos are destroyed or unused.
The Vatican’s oppositional stance against IVF stems from the separation of procreation from the natural act of marital intimacy, which the Church views as human life from the moment of conception. Pope Francis has reinforced this stance, emphasizing the dignity of human life and the importance of respecting natural law in family creation.
He upholds the Church’s teaching that every child should be conceived naturally within the confines of marriage.
What Are the Church-Approved Alternatives to IVF?
The Catholic Church advocates for alternatives to IVF that respect natural conception and the sanctity of life. One Church-approved alternative is NaProTechnology (Natural Procreative Technology), a reproductive science that works with a woman’s natural cycle to diagnose and treat underlying fertility issues.
Did You Know?
Unlike IVF, which creates life outside the body, NaProTechnology focuses on restoring the body's ability to conceive naturally through medical treatments, hormone therapies and lifestyle adjustments. NaProTechnology is seen as an ethical solution because it aligns with the Church's view that conception should occur within marital intimacy and without harm to embryos.
Surrogacy and the Catholic Church
While the Catholic Church opposes IVF, it encourages alternative approaches to family-building that align with Catholic beliefs. Adoption is viewed as a loving way for couples to become parents while respecting the dignity of all life. Fertility treatments that assist the natural procreative process without replacing it are also considered acceptable.
When it comes to surrogacy, Pope Francis called the practice "deplorable" in a speech where he expressed concerns about the exploitation of surrogates, particularly in countries with little regulation. His criticism stems not only from the Church’s teachings on IVF but also from ethical concerns about the treatment of surrogates in vulnerable situations.
However, this view can be seen as an overgeneralization, as it doesn’t fully account for the thorough screening and ethical practices in modern U.S. surrogacy, where agencies work to protect both intended parents and surrogates.
Can Catholics Pursue IVF and Surrogacy While Respecting Their Faith?
Catholics face a complex challenge when considering IVF and surrogacy, as both practices are prohibited by the Church due to concerns over separating procreation from the marital act and the potential harm to embryos. Despite this, many Catholics still choose IVF to have children, highlighting the tension between personal desires and religious teachings.
Some may seek guidance from spiritual advisors or choose fertility treatments that align more closely with their faith, like NaProTechnology, which respects the natural process of conception.
The Catholics opinion on IVF argues that it separates the act of love from procreation, which is intended to happen within a marital relationship. This disconnect raises concerns about the dignity of the human person and the sanctity of marriage. A significant ethical issue involves the fate of unused embryos. Catholic teaching holds that human life begins at conception, making the destruction or freezing of embryos morally unacceptable. In cases where donor eggs, sperm, or a surrogate is used, the Church views this as introducing a third party into the marital relationship, undermining the exclusive bond between husband and wife.Ethical Questions Surrounding the Catholic Church and IVF
Confused about how a surrogate gets pregnant? Learn more about how the surrogacy medical process works here.
Your Next Steps
Whatever path you decide to take, we’ll be here to support you every step of the way. If you're ready to begin your surrogacy journey or want to learn more about alternative family-building options, contact us today. We understand the delicate balance between faith and family, and we’re here to help you explore all of your options.